Polly Ann Bakery

Ordered a cake in the past. Easily the best birthday cake I’ve ever had. A little pricy, but you get what you pay for.

Also, I enjoy reading aloud some of the lower rating reviews in what I think is a “Karen” voice.

The BEST birthday cake I have ever ordered. It was a reasonable price! Exactly what I pictured! It wasn’t “too” sugary like other cakes so it was PERFECT! Easy to just go in and order! Recommend for sure! This is going to be my go to place for custom made cakes! Thank you thank you! Also, the staff are very nice and super helpful!

Been going here for years and I love it. Stay simple and keep making great pastries.

Good bakery with lots of choices to choose from if you do an unexpected visit. Prices are reasonable. Very delicious.

I must say....the wedding cake they made for us was INSANE!!! LOOK AT THE PICTURE! LIke...HOLY COW. Breathtaking. It stole the show for our audience during my wedding. The whole Polly Ann Bakery team deserves the highest praise. We collaborated extensively on the design back and forth and they executed 100%.

The owner had a booklet of like 200+ cakes from the past 50+ years and we took inspiration from past cakes for ours. Feel very comfortable as they do so many weddings to Michael's Tuscany Room as well.