Sue & Kim's Pies LLC

Lemon chiffon pie was absolutely AMAZING! We usually order Marylyn’s but they blew them out of the water. Can’t wait to try other pies.

Best pies in NWI! Ordered the triple berry and French silk and both were absolutely delicious. I love that they are homemade and made to order. Placing the order was easy and Kim was quick to respond to my question about pickup. Looking forward to my next order and trying more flavors.

My dad was craving a banana cream pie for Father’s Day. I searched Pie shops and found Sue & Kim’s and decided to take the plunge. This is not my favorite type of pie because they are usually overly sweet. However, this pie was very well balanced and delicious. The banana cream was sweet but not too much, but what balanced it out was a whipped cream topping with little sugar in it. That made each bite very enjoyable. Whipped cream and banana cream layers were about equal thickness and perfect together. Don’t debate, just order a pie! Note that it is best to order at least 1 day ahead.

I ordered 1 sweet potato pie and 1 pecan pie and they both were absolutely delicious and FRESH I must add they were also very balanced in flavor and I could tell a lot of good measuring and effort went into everything which I appreciate😊

My mom made a special request for her 60th birthday: A banana cream pie! Not too many places make *real* banana cream pie, so I was excited to try Sue & Kim's which are made entirely from scratch. Let me tell you, there is a lot of LOVE put into these pies!

The banana cream and chocolate cream pies were 10/10. 11/10! These go to 11! Fresh ingredients, perfect balance, and an amazing, flavorful, crumbly crust. Run, don't walk! Outstanding customer service with a smile!

These are to pie for! :)