Great American Cookies

Small location, but it has everything you need. Always consistently great cookie cakes! They do good personalization as well.

There's nothing but dessert places on hwy 21 now. Great American cookies, Crumbl and epic milkshakes all in walking distance.

I finally managed to get around to going. There's definitely more here than just cookies. Unknown till arrival they have cakes, ice cream and malts too.

Now I've heard several arguments the GAC and crumbl over which was better. I'm here to put that argument to rest.

Crumbl is definitely the better COOKIE place to go as the presentation is better and the cookies definitely gen taste better pending u get a cookie worth having. Also cookies are made to order at crumbl so it's fresh. Great American cookies has more variety but unless u go in at the right time the cookie your get prob isn't freshly made. Plus for people looking for value there's actual bundle deals for cookies. However bundles only for the basic cookies and Will not extend to brownies, cakes, ice cream or double doozies.

Great American cookies does specialized cakes to order (at least 2 days in advance) and allows any current day cookies to be converted into double doozies which is nice. They also serve ice cream and can make malts as well. There's also unlike crumbl areas to sit and eat vs take to go.

The 2 cookies I decided to buy were great the birthday cake doozie and white chocolate macadamia nut. However the cheesecake brownie was a pass. Like crumbl Cookies are probably randomized but unlike crumbl which on social media u can see weeks cookies well in advance you prob can't tell what's available before u arrive unless u call.

Still its a great place IMO if you're looking for more variety in sweets or looking for a custom order or value for large orders for a party or multiple kids. Raw cookie id still prob go to crumbl however....

Love this location!! Super sweet staff as well!! Everyone was so helpful and welcoming. Can’t wait to bring the family back. The caramel ice cream and supreme pecan cookies are our favorites. :)

I went to pick up cookie cake and it had the wrong colors on it. If it had had any color on it besides brown I would have taken it even though it was supposed to be blue and white. An all brown cake is not nice looking for a birthday(need color to be festive). They said they would do another and they did. While I waited I got a drink and a double doozie. The double doozie cookies were so yard when you knocked on it you could hear the knock. Before I ordered the double doozie I asked about the freshness of the cookies and he said they were baked 2 hours prior. I think they were way over baked. I gave 4 stars because they corrected their mistake with the cookie cake and even gave a larger one(because she said that’s all they had). The cake looked nice and to my surprise it was the freshest thing I’ve ever gotten there. I started to not go there for cake because of stale one last year but gave them another try. It was an extra 30 minute wait for the cookie cake but worth it. It was very fresh and good.

I went in just for fun as I wasn't expecting them to be able to make a cookie cake with such short notice but two hours later we got our order. I'm very happy with my experience!