Mayer Bros Cider Mill

Wonderful place!! I ordered 2 Grandma's recipe caramel apple pies for 2 separate family's Thanksgiving dinner. They were astounding!!! Everyone raved about these pies. The most common response was "this is the best apple pie I've ever had"!!!
Of course while there I bought a few "other" things including some apple cider donuts, apple turnovers,preserves, local honey which were also excellent and yummy.
The staff is very open, friendly and helpful in spite of all three people coming and going.
My "hat's off to them" for not buckling under all the hustle and bustle and still keeping smiling faces.
This store/bakery carries a large variety of items and I highly recommend going there.

A cute little must see in West Seneca. Great apple cider slushies and pies and curds!

Absolutely amazing mill that my family has been going to for years! Fantastic donuts, pies and other pastries; huge assortment of local treats, candies and other goodies; and of course, arguably one of (if not THE) best ciders on the planet! Recently expanded parking lots help, but always be prepared to wait in line. Despite being almost constantly busy, they rarely run out of items and always have fresh baked goods, warm and ready to eat.

Highly recommend to any lover of apples or the harvest season! Try a fresh baked cider donut with a cup of their famous cider-slushie. You will not regret it!

My family and I love coming here. We ended up getting a dozen donuts that are always fresh, an apple pie, candy and a gallon of their cider. Oh and of course, cider slushies! Yum!

Come here for the apple cider slushy around this time if year all the time. Stopped by on Labor Day to get a gallon of apple cider and a dozen of donuts. It was pretty busy. There was a long line outside. We waiting about 15 minutes to get in the door. Then had to wait in the long line inside. Only took us able 5 minutes to checkout. Mayor Bros is my favorite brand of apple cider so it was well worth the wait.