Kensington Pies

We ordered 5 of the British Pies, some to enjoy immediately and rest to take home to eat later. They were delicious and we enjoyed them. The owner is a very friendly guy, and explained how to heat up them up at home. I also ordered arancini which was crispy and delicious along with an order of Penne Vodka with chicken. They forgot to add the chicken for which I paid extra and just gave me the pasta without it. I find pasta by itself without any protein as being dull and boring. I didn’t realize it until I was already home. I live too far to have had it corrected. I’m sure it’s an honest mistake, but double check your orders. 5 star from me because of the good quality and unique food and a very friendly owner.

stopped by while in the area for a soccer tournament and wow what a nice surprise in this area. the savory pies are amazing, we had Chicken Curry, and the ham quiche was also very very good. Grabbed some more to take home for the week they were so great.

I cannot say enough good things about this amazing shop!! The pies are so authentic and absolutely delicious. We tried the Steak and Ale pie tonight and can’t wait to try the rest. I spoke to the owner and chef who is so happy to serve British foods from his homeland to Long Island. Having lived in both Scotland and England, I can say that Kensington Pie’s various British treats will transport you right over the pond!! Check it out, you won’t regret it!

As a English guy I was skeptical, but these pies are the real deal. I drove 45 minutes from Patchogue to sample this. I got a Shepard pie and thankfully it was lamb, I got a cheese and onion pasty that I ate on way home and it was like I was on building site in England so good, when I got home I reheated at 350 for 35 mins.
I'm waiting to try the cherry pie that I have but from what I've tasted so far I'm not going to be disappointed.

Found this establishment after reading an article about the owner bringing English meat pies into our area.

Had a great chat with the owner and picked up four meat pies, two Cornish pasties and a scotch egg. All were delicious. We'll definitely return for more!