Blue Line Deli & Bagels

Our new favorite deli. My Fiancée and I were in earlier and the entire staff was welcoming from the jump. Not once rushing us and being sure to clarify our order. The prices were reasonable for the quality and portion offered, and everything was just soo delicious. From the crispy and flavorful bagels, the Honey Mustard Tuna and the Melt-in-your-mouth tender Hot Roast Beef (seriously meaty and so savory). I was going to try their pudding but a brownie was calling to me—and I’m still working through it as I type this! It’s the gift that keeps on giving. We miss places like this.

Thanks so much for the experience, Donnie + Staff. Our family is sure to come back! 🧡💙

This is truly the BEST deli in America. The service is fast and phenomenal- shoutout to Danny behind the counter!! The egg sandwiches are something I dream about.

I make the 2-hour drive to this deli when I'm in town to visit family. The whole staff is welcoming, very nice, and the Isles decor looks amazing. The sandwiches and bagels are delicious, as well as the baked goods. I highly recommend Blue Line Deli.💙🧡

We’ve been going to Blue Line regularly since they opened and it has always been delicious! The staff is very friendly and always ready to talk Islanders hockey. We recently got catering from them for two events and the food was top notch! Both times we ordered the sandwich basket which comes with three very large sides. The sandwiches were super fresh and individually wrapped which my friends liked. There was a great variety, many people had a hard time deciding which sandwich to have. There was SO MUCH FOOD!!! There was a whole second layer of sandwiches under the top layer shown in the photos. With the sides you can pick any of the salads they offer which was a nice change from the typical Cole slaw, potato salad and macaroni salad that typically comes with catering orders from other places. Danny was great taking my order and made sure to ask if there were any dietary restrictions or special sandwiches we needed for our guests. We will most definitely be catering from them again and will continue to go there regularly for breakfast and lunch.