Lighthouse Pizza Corolla

In May of 2022 we visited LIghthouse Pizza. This used to be Pasquale's Pizza - and when it initially changed ownership it was not great. We tried it again on our recent trip - and there has been a change again - for the better! This time, the pizza we ordered was FABULOUS! They even accommodated a special white pizza request that they had not made before. That pizza was so good we drove back to the shop just to tell them how good it was, and to add it as a regular menu item! It is not "NY pizza", so don't go in expecting that - but it is REALLY GOOD pizza. There were some guys right behind us raving about the food, and waiting for their 7 pizza order! The proprietor was extremely accommodating and we are looking forward to our late September trip to visit again for dinner!
7/16/22 UPDATE..My "special" white pizza with ricotta added to the pie along with tomatoes. Reheated from the freezer tonite and just as delicious as it was when we brought the leftovers home with us in May.

We first tried to get pizza on the Saturday evening we arrived in Corolla. But we were too late. It smelled so good, though, that we ordered pizza from Lighthouse on Sunday. We were not disappointed!! My hubby and sister shared a pie and I ordered gluten free sausage and onion. I’m not sure when the last time I had gluten-free pizza that I could fold Jersey-style! We will definitely be back!

Where do I start with letting everyone know this is such a great place to eat. I guess I'll start with saying I'm originally from PA (close to Old Forge where they call themselves the pizza capital of the world 🤷‍♀️... also not far from NY which come on... pizza is also good there!) I've heard it's amazing in other states/countries but I have yet to visit them.
Anywho, I've lived near Raleigh, NC for over 3 years now and haven't really found good pizza yet, so it's not something I typically get to eat anymore. I was recently on vacation in the Outer Banks and while driving around my friend found this place to stop to eat at. I was hesitant at first. But... this place did not disappoint. From the moment I walked in to place my order, the lady behind the counter was a lovely nice person. We ordered just a regular plain pie so I didn't have high expectations to begin with. I say that because they have some great choices for specialty pizzas. (My friend is boring though when it comes to extras 😂) I let the woman know we'd be outside ( I didn't notice any seating inside plus I had my dog with me) and she said they would let me know when it was ready. I assumed she'd just open the door and yell out that it was ready. Nope. A nice gentleman carried it down the steps in the box with paper plates and napkins to the cute outdoor covered area where we were sitting. Immediately opened the box and it was piping hot, looked great too. Took my first bite...soooo good. I didn't need any garlic powder, salt, pepper, or whatever else we sometimes feel the need to put on our pizza. Lol. I'll end this long review with saying, you should definitely stop in if you are passing by or staying local and you're hungry! I didn't try anything else on menu but I'm sure everything is great! Can't wait to come back!

Couldn’t wait and take the picture first. This was some of the best pizza I have ever had. Delicious sauce, the crust has the perfect crunchy outside and dense bready inside. Can’t say enough nice things about this pie.

This place was Amazing. A family owned business. They are very kind and the pizza was amazing. When you pull the slice out the melt on that cheese 😍. Do recommend 100%