Italiano's Pizzaria And catering

Wow! This pizza is exactly what I have been looking for since moving to Geauga county! It was perfect!

I have ordered from here multiple times and overall I do like the food. I have gotten the meatlovers pizza a few times and it is always delicious, their meatballs are also very good and I’m really picky about meatballs but I liked these ones. Now the fried wings are breaded and we got them with mild sauce but it came with almost no sauce on them and they were pretty greasy. And I’ve gotten their Italian sub which isn’t bad but I do feel like it needs more toppings on them and I’m not the biggest fan of the shredded cheese they put on it.

This place is great! Our first visit and I have passed it for 10 years and never stopped. Well tonight was my stepsons 16 birthday with some family, and I couldn’t think of a place on the way home, then I remembered this place and YES! We will be back, pizza was perfectly cooked in and only school kind of way, the crumbled sausage was my favorite! Fresh salad and rolls, the balsamic dressing it’s awesome too! We also got the pasta which was a great hit! (Sorry I didn’t actually try it). But I wish I would have tipped the very nice very very busy lady behind the counter. She did a great job and worked as fast as she could. The next time, which will be soon, I will make up for it! Thanks for the great food and service!

When you see the Italian colors & a beautiful outdoor patio, you know you can’t lose with great food & cold bottled beer.....

Italiano’s Pizzaria is in Mantua, a rolling & beautiful suburb that’s southeast of Cleveland, Ohio. Mantua is located in a more rural area on RT 44 just north of I-80 and south of RT 422. Italiano’s has parking around the building. It’s a quiet, casual dining experience, typical of a small pizzaria & great for any type of crowd. There was no waiting time.

The serving sizes were huge! However, we were mixed on the food with a few suggestions. Rigatoni (penne) homemade pasta dinner and Kamden’s Rigatoni (penne) with Meatball & Kids’ Juice Box were great with a fabulous original sauciness & positives on flavor. The side of house-made meatballs were good but could use a bit more flavor flare to really hit. Served with fresh made bread & butter that was completely amazing.

Italiano 1/2 Pound Burger with Capicola, Ham, Salami, Lettuce, Tomato, & Creamy Italian Dressing had potential, but it was a bit well-done, partially my fault for not mentioning how I prefer burgers cooked. As a suggestion, I would prefer the meat only slightly cooked and not full-out fried. The fried deli meats reminded me of childhood “fried bologna” .....lol..... Note to self, when dining at an Italian restaurant, go for what they specialize or ask for what they’re famous?

Trevor was an exceptional server. The pizzaria’s staff were all friendly. Food prep was about thirty (30) minutes. The food was professionally plated with generous pasta & equally generous sauce portions in what literally seemed to be never-ending bowls. I would definitely choose Italiano’s over any Italian chain, because the value was unbeatable. Our family of four (4) ate, had plenty of leftovers, plus left a legit tip for Trevor, and all for less than $50. I’d love to jump around their menu, because they had so much to offer!